The Council of Europe, 1949: A Parliament Without Power and the Convention That Gave It Teeth

How the Council of Europe was founded in 1949 as a compromise between federalists and sceptics.

Published by Writesides of History, independent publisherBibliography: 5 sources ↓ How we work

St James's Palace — A Parliament Without Power and the Convention That Gave It Teeth — with St James's Palace, London

On 5 May 1949, ten European governments signed a statute at St James's Palace in London that created the Council of Europe, the continent's first postwar political organisation. It was designed to have almost no power, yet its most durable creation, the European Convention on Human Rights, became one of the most consequential treaties of the twentieth century.

A continent looking for a shape

By 1946 Europe was a patchwork of ruined economies and occupation zones. In Zurich on 19 September 1946, Winston Churchill, then out of office, called for "a kind of United States of Europe" and urged his audience: "Let Europe arise." His speech is often read as a blueprint, but he spoke of France and Germany leading, with Britain as a friend and sponsor rather than a member. That ambiguity, a Britain that wanted a united Europe but did not wish to dissolve into it, shaped everything that followed.

Practical cooperation moved faster than political union. The Marshall Plan obliged Western European states to coordinate their requests for American aid, and the crisis over Berlin, described in the Berlin Airlift, hardened the sense of a divided continent. In March 1948 Britain, France, and the Benelux countries signed the Treaty of Brussels, a defensive alliance. Alongside these state-led efforts, a private movement was pushing for something more ambitious.

The Hague Congress and the great quarrel

From 7 to 11 May 1948, roughly 750 delegates from across Western Europe gathered in The Hague for the Congress of Europe, with Churchill as honorary president. Politicians, trade unionists, and academics called for a European assembly, a charter of human rights, and a court to enforce it.

The congress exposed the central dispute of the following year. Federalists, found mostly in France, Belgium, and Italy, wanted an assembly with real authority. The British Labour government, led on foreign policy by Ernest Bevin, preferred cooperation between governments that kept their vetoes. Historians generally describe the Statute as the compromise between these two camps, and its structure bears this out: a Committee of Ministers, where each government held a veto, and a Consultative Assembly, which could debate and recommend but not legislate.

What the Statute actually created

The Statute declared that the aim was "to achieve a greater unity between its members" for safeguarding their common ideals and facilitating economic and social progress. It also excluded "matters relating to national defence" from the Council's work. Because the Council could not legislate and could not touch defence, it stood apart from the military alliance that would emerge with NATO in 1949, a story that connects to NATO's intelligence networks.

The founding members were Belgium, Denmark, France, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Norway, Sweden, and the United Kingdom. The Assembly met for the first time in Strasbourg on 10 August 1949, and the Belgian statesman Paul-Henri Spaak was elected its president. Greece and Turkey joined in 1949, Iceland in 1950, and West Germany became a full member in 1951.

The Convention: rights as a Cold War argument

The human rights project that had been demanded at The Hague came to fruition in Rome on 4 November 1950, when the members signed the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms. Its drafting drew heavily on British lawyers such as David Maxwell Fyfe, a prosecutor at Nuremberg, and on French politicians such as Pierre-Henri Teitgen. The treaty entered into force on 3 September 1953.

Its motives were mixed. Some of its supporters saw it as a defence against a return of dictatorship; others saw it as a statement against communism in the East. Some historians, including A. W. Brian Simpson, have also stressed the part played by British worries about colonial policy, since Britain pressed for a clause that allowed it to decide whether the Convention applied to its overseas territories. The disagreements show that the treaty was not simply the product of idealism.

Chronology

Date Event
19 Sept 1946 Churchill's Zurich speech
March 1948 Treaty of Brussels signed
7-11 May 1948 Congress of Europe at The Hague
5 May 1949 Statute signed in London
10 Aug 1949 First Assembly session in Strasbourg
4 Nov 1950 Convention signed in Rome
3 Sept 1953 Convention enters into force
1959 European Court of Human Rights established
1998 Protocol 11 makes the Court permanent

From optional to indispensable

In its first years the Convention's machinery was timid. States could choose whether to accept the right of individuals to petition, and the Court, which sat for the first time in 1959, heard few cases. The United Kingdom accepted individual petition only in 1966. Protocol 11, which took effect in 1998, abolished the old Commission, made the Court permanent, and made individual petition automatic for every member state.

Enlargement transformed the organisation after 1989. Spain joined in 1977, and states emerging from communism followed, Russia among them in 1996. The Council now has 46 member states according to its own treaty records. Russia was expelled in March 2022 after its invasion of Ukraine. Today the Council is often confused with the European Union, though it is a separate body; its relationship to the project begun in the Schuman Plan and the Treaty of Rome is one of shared aspirations but different powers.

Conclusion

The Council of Europe was born of a quarrel and its weakness was deliberate. The federalists did not get a parliament, and the sceptics did not get a purely diplomatic club. What emerged was a modest framework that later accommodated a rights treaty whose reach no one in 1949 can have fully predicted. Its history shows how institutions often outgrow their founders' intentions, and how far the later story of integration, including the fall of the Berlin Wall, depended on structures built in the late 1940s.

Frequently asked questions

Is the Council of Europe part of the European Union? No. The Council of Europe is a separate organisation founded in 1949 and based in Strasbourg, while the European Union grew from the Coal and Steel Community and the Treaty of Rome. The two do not share institutions, and the Convention is enforced by the European Court of Human Rights, not by the EU's Court of Justice.

Why was the Council of Europe given so little power? The British government and others insisted on keeping national vetoes, so the Statute created a Committee of Ministers that decided by agreement and an Assembly that could only recommend. Federalists wanted more, and the result is generally read as a compromise.

When did the Convention on Human Rights take effect? It was signed in Rome on 4 November 1950 and entered into force on 3 September 1953. The Court itself began sitting in 1959, and individual petition became compulsory for all members only with Protocol 11 in 1998.

Which countries founded the Council? Ten states signed the Statute in London on 5 May 1949: Belgium, Denmark, France, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, the Netherlands, Norway, Sweden, and the United Kingdom.

Bibliography

  • Churchill, Winston S. Speech delivered at the University of Zurich, 19 September 1946. 1946.
  • Europe, Council of. Treaty Office: Chart of signatures and ratifications. Council of Europe, 2022.
  • Europe, Council of. Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (Rome, 4 November 1950). Council of Europe Treaty Series No. 5, 1950.
  • Europe, Council of. Statute of the Council of Europe (London, 5 May 1949). Council of Europe Treaty Series No. 1, 1949.
  • Milward, Alan S. The Reconstruction of Western Europe, 1945-51. Routledge, 1984.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate links in Recommended reading — and in Further reading on older articles — may earn Writesides of History a commission at no extra cost to you.

Free for the curious, supported by you

Writesides of History publishes free, in-depth history articles every week. If you enjoy reading, you can support the work: become a member for exclusive deep-dive dossiers and early access, or browse the maps, classroom packs and dossiers in the shop.

Become a Member Donate Visit the Shop