Richard the Lionheart in Captivity: Dürnstein, an Emperor and a King's Ransom
How Richard I was seized near Vienna in December 1192, held at Dürnstein and then by the Emperor, and freed in 1194 for a ransom of 150,000 marks.
In December 1192 the most famous crusader in Europe was arrested in a village outside Vienna, and for the next fourteen months the King of England was a prisoner of men who had fought beside him at Acre. The Third Crusade ended at Jaffa with a truce, but Richard's war did not end there. It continued as a contest of letters, hostages and silver, and it was fought in German castles rather than on the coast of Palestine.
Why Richard went home by land
Richard left Acre on 9 October 1192, six weeks after the truce sworn at Jaffa. He had good reason to hurry. His brother John was intriguing in England, and Philip II of France, who had left the crusade early, was pressing against the Angevin lands in Normandy. The sea route home through the Mediterranean was the natural one, but it ran past Provence and the territory of the count of Toulouse, with whom Richard had old quarrels.
According to the chroniclers, he was wrecked on the northern Adriatic coast near Aquileia in late autumn. Roger of Howden and the Itinerarium both record that he then tried to cross the Holy Roman Empire in disguise, travelling as a pilgrim with a very small retinue. The disguise was a serious attempt at survival. By the summer of 1192 Richard had enemies in two courts at least, and the lands he now had to cross belonged to men with scores to settle.
The men with a grievance
Duke Leopold V of Austria had served at the siege of Acre. After the city fell in July 1191, banners were raised on its walls, and according to a tradition found in the chronicles, Richard's men tore down the duke's standard and threw it into a ditch. Whether the incident happened exactly so is uncertain, and the sources are partisan, but the quarrel clearly went deep. The duke had also lost a share of the spoils of Acre, and he left the crusade soon afterwards.
A second grievance belonged to the Emperor. In April 1192 Conrad of Montferrat, elected king of Jerusalem, was stabbed to death in Tyre. Rumour, much of it spread by Philip II's circle, laid the murder at Richard's door. Modern historians generally doubt that Richard ordered it, but the accusation was useful to anyone who wanted a pretext. Henry VI, who had recently succeeded Frederick Barbarossa and had his own designs on Sicily, was also hostile to the Angevin alliance with the Welf family, his rivals inside the Empire.
The arrest
Richard was recognised near Vienna. The sources differ on the details: the usual date given is around 20 or 21 December 1192, and the place most often named is the village of Erdberg. A common version holds that he was betrayed by his manner, or by a ring or a page's money, which gave away his rank. The story is told with relish and should be treated as the kind of detail chroniclers liked to add, rather than as fact.
What the sources do agree on is that Leopold's officers seized him and that the duke held him in custody at Dürnstein, a fortress above the Danube in the Wachau. Some modern accounts hedge a little and say Dürnstein "or a neighbouring castle". The ruined castle is the place named by tradition and local memory, and it is a reasonable conclusion rather than a documented certainty.
The Blondel story belongs to this stage only in legend. In the best-known telling, the minstrel Blondel travelled from fortress to fortress singing a song he and the king had composed, until a voice answered from a tower. The tale is a later invention, and it appears to be a romantic way of explaining how the king's whereabouts became known. Richard's captivity was not secret for long: the emperor and the duke were negotiating openly, and Philip II knew where he was.
Chronology
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 2 Sept 1192 | Truce sworn at Jaffa |
| 9 Oct 1192 | Richard sails from Acre |
| Late Nov – Dec 1192 | Shipwreck on the Adriatic coast; overland journey in disguise |
| c. 20–21 Dec 1192 | Arrested near Vienna by Duke Leopold's men |
| Dec 1192 – early 1193 | Held at Dürnstein (traditional place) |
| Feb – Mar 1193 | Handed to Emperor Henry VI and moved into imperial custody |
| 1193 | Trials and negotiations; ransom fixed at 150,000 marks |
| 4 Feb 1194 | Richard released at Mainz after homage to the Emperor |
| 13 Mar 1194 | Richard lands in England |
From duke to emperor
Leopold did not keep his prisoner. Holding a crusader was dangerous: a crusader was under the protection of the Church, and Pope Celestine III excommunicated those who had seized him. The duke therefore passed Richard to the Emperor, who had the standing to charge him and the power to bargain. By the spring of 1193 the king was in imperial custody at fortresses such as Trifels, and at an assembly held at Speyer he was formally answered with a list of accusations, including the death of Conrad and his dealings with Tancred in Sicily. According to Howden, he defended himself so eloquently that the charges collapsed in the hearing.
Henry VI wanted money. Philip II and Richard's brother John offered the Emperor silver to keep the king in prison, and Philip's message to John, as Howden reports it, was that the devil was loose and John should look to himself. The offer was real. Henry weighed it against the sum Richard's mother and ministers could raise.
The ransom
The figure agreed in 1193 was 150,000 marks of silver, which Howden records and which modern scholars accept as the standard number. The Emperor's terms also required Richard to surrender his kingdom to Henry and receive it back as a fief, a symbolic submission that the English tolerated because it bought freedom. Estimates of what the sum meant for the crown vary, but it is usually described as a multiple of the king's yearly income, and the strain of raising it was felt across the realm.
Eleanor of Aquitaine, then close to seventy, took charge of the collection, and Hubert Walter, the bishop who governed England, helped to organise it. A heavy levy was laid on the kingdom: a quarter of the value of movable goods and income, the plate of churches, and contributions from monasteries. This was the same fiscal machinery that had been tested at the Saladin tithe of 1188, now turned to freeing the king who had spent the proceeds. The sum was not complete when Richard was freed. Hostages were left with the Emperor as security for the balance.
Our record of the king's campaigns, the Richard I dataset, shows how little of his reign was spent in the field after this point, and how much of what followed was a war to recover what had been lost in his absence.
Release and aftermath
On 4 February 1194 Richard was released at Mainz after paying homage to Henry VI. He reached England in March, was crowned a second time at Winchester, and by May was crossing back to Normandy to fight Philip. He never returned to England again. His war in France, which ended with his death at Châlus in 1199, was financed in part by the same kingdom that had paid for his freedom.
Leopold's end was grimmer. Contemporaries recorded that he had been excommunicated for seizing a crusader, and that he died in December 1194 after a riding accident. A share of the ransom was used on projects in Austria, among them the strengthening of towns such as Wiener Neustadt. His son received the duchy.
Conclusion
The captivity is often told as a story of treachery and a loyal minstrel. The documents tell something more useful: that a crusading king could be seized on his way home because his enemies, rather than any rule of war, decided he should be, and that the Church's protection of crusaders carried real weight only when someone with power chose to enforce it. The ransom turned the personal quarrel into public finance, and what England paid for it shaped both Richard's remaining years and the politics of the generation after him.
Frequently asked questions
Was Richard really held at Dürnstein? Tradition says so, and it is the place most often named in later accounts. Some modern writers prefer to say Dürnstein "or a neighbouring castle", because the contemporary sources are not equally specific about where in Leopold's lands he was kept.
Did a minstrel called Blondel find him? Almost certainly not. The story appears in later tradition and reads as a romantic explanation for how the king was located, but the powers involved already knew where he was.
How much was the ransom? The figure given in the chronicles is 150,000 marks of silver. It was paid in stages, with hostages standing as security for the remainder, and the burden fell on the English clergy, towns and landholders.
Why was Richard seized at all? Leopold of Austria nursed a grievance from the siege of Acre, and the Emperor Henry VI had political reasons to be hostile to Richard's allies. Richard's status as a crusader should have protected him, and the Church condemned the arrest, but it did not stop it.
Bibliography
- Gillingham, John. Richard I. Yale University Press, 1999.
- Nicholson, Anonymous; trans. Helen J. Chronicle of the Third Crusade: A Translation of the Itinerarium Peregrinorum et Gesta Regis Ricardi. Ashgate, 1997.
- Riley, Roger of Howden; trans. Henry T. The Annals of Roger de Hoveden. H. G. Bohn, 1853.
- Turner, Ralph V. Eleanor of Aquitaine: Queen of France, Queen of England. Yale University Press, 2009.
Recommended reading
God's War: A New History of the Crusadesplaces the Third Crusade and its aftermath in the long history of crusading.
The Crusades: The Authoritative History of the War for the Holy Landa readable single-volume narrative that carries the story of the Third Crusade through to its end.
View on Amazon ->: The Crusades: The Authoritative History of the War for the Holy Land
The Angevin Empirea concise analysis of how the Angevin dominion was governed and why a king's absence put it at risk.
The History of the Holy War: Ambroise's Estoire de la Guerre Saintethe eyewitness verse chronicle of the campaign that led to the journey home.
View on Amazon ->: The History of the Holy War: Ambroise's Estoire de la Guerre Sainte
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate links in Recommended reading — and in Further reading on older articles — may earn Writesides of History a commission at no extra cost to you.
Free for the curious, supported by you
Writesides of History publishes free, in-depth history articles every week. If you enjoy reading, you can support the work: become a member for exclusive deep-dive dossiers and early access, or browse the maps, classroom packs and dossiers in the shop.
Become a Member Donate Visit the Shop