Cornelis Evertsen the Youngest and the Dutch Recapture of New York, 1673
In August 1673 Zeeland's Cornelis Evertsen the Youngest and Jacob Binckes retook New York for the Dutch.
On 9 August 1673 (New Style) a Dutch fleet anchored under the guns of Fort James at the southern tip of Manhattan, and within hours the English garrison had surrendered. The man giving the orders was Cornelis Evertsen the Youngest, a hot-tempered vice-admiral from Zeeland who had not been sent to New York at all. His real instructions pointed at Saint Helena and Cayenne; New York was what he found when those plans failed. The Dutch renamed the city New Orange and held it for fifteen months, until a peace treaty gave it back.
A Zeeland admiral from a family of admirals
Cornelis Evertsen the Youngest was born in Vlissingen (Flushing) in 1642 and died in 1706. He was the son of Lieutenant-Admiral Cornelis Evertsen the Elder and the nephew of Johan Evertsen, whose own son, also Cornelis, is called Cornelis Evertsen the Younger. The extra superlative keeps the two cousins apart, though they are still often confused.
The family belonged to the Admiralty of Zeeland, one of the five regional colleges that ran the Republic's navy, a system explained in the five admiralties of the Dutch Republic. According to the standard biographical summary, Evertsen went to sea on his father's ship at the age of ten, served in the Second Anglo-Dutch War, and fought in the battles of 1666, in which both his father and his uncle are reported to have died. A year later he took part in the raid on Chatham. The Zeeuws Archief describes him as hotheaded.
The war that put him across the Atlantic
The Third Anglo-Dutch War grew out of the crisis told in the disaster year of 1672. It was fought mostly in home waters, but Zeeland, with its heavy investment in overseas trade, wanted to strike at English possessions too.
The plan, as the Zeeuws Archief tells it, was this. Evertsen, as vice-admiral, was to take a squadron of six ships to capture Saint Helena, the South Atlantic island on the English East India Company's route home. The Dutch East India Company had in fact already taken it, so that goal evaporated. His orders named a fallback, Cayenne in French Guiana. Judging his force too weak for that, Evertsen instead joined a larger fleet under Jacob Binckes of the Amsterdam Admiralty, which was operating in the Caribbean. The conquest of New York was therefore an improvised decision, and it is why Evertsen was later in trouble.
From the Caribbean to Virginia
The two squadrons joined near Guadeloupe and formed a joint command, with Evertsen sailing in the Swaenenburgh. They turned north. In July 1673 they went into Chesapeake waters, where, in what is called the Second Battle of the James River, they captured or destroyed a large part of the English tobacco fleet. Tobacco and captured ships were the kind of loot that paid for a Zeeland expedition, and the Dutch arrived off New York with prizes in tow.
Why the fleet then chose New York is not clearly documented in the sources we have. One reading is that it was always one possible target; another, closer to the Zeeuws Archief's account, is that the admirals saw an opportunity when they heard how weakly it was held.
Chronology
| Date | Event |
|---|---|
| 1642 | Evertsen born in Vlissingen |
| 1666 | Fights in the Four Days Battle and St James's Day Battle; father and uncle killed |
| 1667 | Takes part in the Medway raid |
| 1672 | Third Anglo-Dutch War begins; orders to take Saint Helena and then Cayenne |
| July 1673 | Joins Binckes; action in Virginia waters against the tobacco fleet |
| 28 July 1673 (OS) | Dutch fleet arrives off Staten Island |
| 30 July 1673 (OS) / 9 August (NS) | Fort James surrenders; city renamed New Orange |
| February 1674 | Treaty of Westminster ends the war |
| July 1674 | Evertsen returns to Zeeland to a cool reception |
| 10 November 1674 (NS) | Transfer back to English rule |
The day Fort James fell
The Dutch fleet reached Staten Island on 28 July 1673 in the English calendar. Accounts differ on its size: the Zeeuws Archief and Wikipedia's text give 21 ships, while Wikipedia's infobox gives nine, and the difference probably lies in whether prizes are counted.
The English garrison under Captain John Manning numbered about a hundred men. Dutch farmers, according to the Zeeuws Archief, reported that the fort was poorly defended, and Evertsen decided to attack the next day.
On the morning of 9 August (New Style) a trumpeter demanded surrender. English envoys came aboard Evertsen's ship that afternoon; he gave them half an hour to decide. When that ran out and nothing had been settled he opened fire. In the version that has come down to us, Evertsen told the English that his commission was "stuck in the barrel" of his guns, a remark reported later and best treated with caution.
While the ships bombarded the fort, about 600 sailors and marines went ashore north of the town under Captain Anthony Colve, who marched them down Broadway, then called the Heerenstraat, to the fort. Colonists are reported to have cheered them on. Manning raised a white flag and asked for honourable terms. The garrison marched out with the honours of war and laid down its arms. According to the Wikipedia account, the Dutch had no casualties and the English lost about a hundred men as prisoners. Governor Francis Lovelace later asked for safe-conduct to negotiate.
New Orange
The Dutch lost no time in rebranding. The city became New Orange, after the stadtholder William III, and Fort James became Fort Willem Hendrick. The province recovered its old name, New Netherland. Colve, who had led the landing, was made director of the colony, with orders to fortify it against the expected move from New England.
Behind the new names lay uncertainty. The New Orange council wrote to Zeeland in September 1673 and again in January 1674, asking for men and supplies. Zeeland was reluctant, according to the Zeeuws Archief. The province had just paid heavily for the disaster year and for the earlier conquest of Suriname, and the States General preferred that Amsterdam should govern the colony. The older colony had rested on trade with Native peoples, a story told in Dutch trade with the Indigenous peoples of the Hudson.
Handed back
The fall of New Orange did not decide anything on the European side of the war. The Treaty of Westminster, concluded in February 1674, ended the war between England and the Republic. Under its terms the Dutch gave up New Netherland, and in exchange kept Suriname. News reached New Orange in May 1674, and the formal transfer took place on 10 November 1674 (New Style), when Edmund Andros took over from Colve. New York was English again, and it has stayed under that name since.
Russell Shorto's history of the colony argues that the Dutch period shaped the city's character long after the flag changed. That is an interpretation, not a documented fact, but a widely shared one.
Evertsen's reward
Evertsen returned to Zeeland in July 1674 to a cool reception. He was accused of abandoning his assignment and of sharing the profits of captured ships with people from Holland.
His career survived the criticism. In 1679 he became vice-admiral of Zeeland, and in 1684 lieutenant-admiral, which made him the supreme commander of the Dutch fleet. According to the biographical summary, he helped organise the invasion fleet that carried William III to England in 1688 and commanded its vanguard. At Beachy Head in 1690 he led the allied vanguard against a larger French fleet; he was replaced as supreme commander the same year and never again led a fleet.
Other Dutch naval actions are recorded, with a graded certainty for each, in our record of Dutch Golden Age naval battles. The wider question of how contemporary sources count ships and losses is discussed in ship counts and loss figures in Dutch sea battles.
Conclusion
The recapture of New York in 1673 was a small, quick and almost bloodless operation, carried out by a commander who was improvising after his official mission had collapsed. It showed what one Zeeland admiral and a few hundred marines could do on the far side of the Atlantic. It also showed the limits of Dutch ambition: no province was willing to pay for a colony that the peace table would soon trade away.
Frequently asked questions
Who retook New York for the Dutch in 1673? Two admirals did it together: Cornelis Evertsen the Youngest of the Admiralty of Zeeland and Jacob Binckes of the Admiralty of Amsterdam. Anthony Colve led the landing party and then became the colony's director.
Was New York recaptured on purpose? The evidence suggests it was largely opportunistic. Evertsen's orders were to take Saint Helena and then Cayenne, and he turned to Binckes's fleet and the North American coast only after those aims failed. He was later criticised for it in Zeeland.
What happened to New York after the recapture? The Dutch renamed the city New Orange and the fort Fort Willem Hendrick. The Treaty of Westminster of February 1674 returned New Netherland to England, and the transfer was completed on 10 November 1674 (New Style).
Why did the Dutch give it back? The treaty ended the war, and under it the Republic kept Suriname while giving up New Netherland. Zeeland and the States General were also unwilling to pay to defend a distant colony after the costs of 1672.
Bibliography
- Archief, Zeeuws. 'Zeeuw' conquers New York. Zeeuws Archief, Middelburg.
- contributors, Wikipedia. Cornelis Evertsen the Youngest. Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia.
- contributors, Wikipedia. Reconquest of New Netherland. Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia.
- Shorto, Russell. The Island at the Center of the World. Doubleday, 2004.
Recommended reading
The Dutch Republic: Its Rise, Greatness, and Fall 1477-1806the standard single-volume account of the state that sent Evertsen across the Atlantic.
View on Amazon ->: The Dutch Republic: Its Rise, Greatness, and Fall 1477-1806
The Dutch Navy of the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuriesthe best study of the admiralties, ships and officers behind these campaigns.
View on Amazon ->: The Dutch Navy of the Seventeenth and Eighteenth Centuries
The Anglo-Dutch Wars of the Seventeenth Centurya compact narrative of the third war and the treaty that ended it.
View on Amazon ->: The Anglo-Dutch Wars of the Seventeenth Century
War, Trade and the State: Anglo-Dutch Conflict, 1652-89essays that set the wars in their commercial and political context.
View on Amazon ->: War, Trade and the State: Anglo-Dutch Conflict, 1652-89
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Affiliate links in Recommended reading — and in Further reading on older articles — may earn Writesides of History a commission at no extra cost to you.
Free for the curious, supported by you
Writesides of History publishes free, in-depth history articles every week. If you enjoy reading, you can support the work: become a member for exclusive deep-dive dossiers and early access, or browse the maps, classroom packs and dossiers in the shop.
Become a Member Donate Visit the Shop